Breast Lift vs. Breast Augmentation: Do I Need a Lift, Implants, or Both?
One of the most common questions women have when considering breast surgery is whether they need a breast lift, breast augmentation, or both.
The simplest way to understand the difference is to think about breast shape and breast volume as two separate, but closely related, decisions.
A breast lift primarily changes the shape and position of the breast. Breast augmentation primarily changes its size and volume. In the right patient, combining the two gives us the ability to change both breast shape and breast proportions.
Understanding what each procedure actually does is the first step in deciding which operation, or combination of operations, may best accomplish your goals.
What Does a Breast Lift Do?
A breast lift, or mastopexy, is primarily a breast reshaping operation.
With pregnancy, breastfeeding, weight changes, aging, or simply genetics, the breast skin can stretch and the breast tissue can descend. The nipple and areola may also move lower on the breast.
A breast lift allows us to reposition and reshape the breast tissue, remove excess skin, and move the nipple and areola into a position that is appropriate for the newly shaped breast.
The objective is not simply to move the nipple higher. The goal is to create a more attractive breast shape, with the breast tissue, skin envelope, nipple, and areola all working together.
How Much Scarring Does a Breast Lift Require?
Because a breast lift reshapes the skin envelope, it requires external incisions. The amount and location of the scars depend largely on how much reshaping and skin removal are necessary.
The scar can range from a small crescent-shaped incision above the nipple-areola complex to a circumareolar incision around the areola, a vertical or “lollipop” lift, or a full anchor-pattern lift.
In patients with significant excess skin extending toward the side of the chest, the incision can sometimes be extended laterally to remove this tissue and improve the transition between the breast and axilla.
The important concept is that the scar pattern should be determined by the amount of reshaping the breast requires. A smaller scar is not necessarily a better operation if it does not allow us to create the breast shape the patient wants.
What Does Breast Augmentation Do?
Breast augmentation is different.
Its primary purpose is to add volume to the breast.
Traditionally, this is accomplished with a breast implant. Unlike a breast lift, breast augmentation can usually be performed through a relatively small incision.
Breast implants can be placed through several approaches, including an incision in the inframammary fold beneath the breast, around the areola, through the axilla, or, in selected cases, through the umbilicus.
In selected patients undergoing an abdominoplasty at the same time, breast implants can even be placed through the abdominal exposure, avoiding an additional breast incision. This is a specialized approach and is not appropriate for every patient.
Regardless of the incision, the fundamental purpose of augmentation remains the same: to increase breast volume and change breast proportions.
Implants Are Not the Only Way to Add Breast Volume
Breast enhancement does not necessarily require an implant.
Fat transfer to the breasts can add volume using a patient’s own tissue. It can be particularly useful for patients seeking a relatively modest increase in size, improving contour or asymmetry, or adding volume to specific areas of the breast.
Another option in carefully selected patients is the use of autologous tissue, including tissue from the lateral breast or axillary region that can be repositioned to enhance breast shape and volume.
These techniques generally provide a more limited increase in size than an implant, but in the right patient they can be extremely effective.
There are also situations in which an implant and fat transfer can be used together. This hybrid breast augmentation allows the implant to provide the primary volume while fat is strategically added to refine the shape, soften transitions, improve symmetry, or provide additional soft-tissue coverage.
Breast Lift Changes Shape. Breast Augmentation Changes Volume.
This is the most important distinction.
A breast lift primarily addresses shape and position.
A breast augmentation primarily addresses volume and size.
An implant can sometimes improve the appearance of mild breast drooping by restoring lost volume, but an implant does not truly perform a breast lift.
Similarly, a breast lift can dramatically improve breast shape without necessarily giving a patient the increase in breast size or upper-pole fullness she wants.
This is why deciding whether someone needs a lift or augmentation should begin by separating the problem into two questions:
Do I like the size and volume of my breasts?
Do I like their shape and position?
The answers to those two questions help determine the operation.
When Do You Need Both a Breast Lift and Augmentation?
Some women are happy with their breast volume but unhappy with sagging or shape. They may need a lift without an implant.
Others have a good breast shape and nipple position but simply want larger or fuller breasts. They may need augmentation without a lift.
Many women, however—particularly after pregnancy, breastfeeding, significant weight loss, or aging, experience both loss of volume and loss of shape.
These patients may benefit from combining breast augmentation with a breast lift.
The lift reshapes and repositions the existing breast. The augmentation restores or adds volume.
The two procedures therefore perform different but symbiotic roles.
One helps establish the breast envelope, shape, and position. The other helps determine volume, projection, and fullness.
When thoughtfully combined, they give us considerable control over both the shape and proportions of the breast.
Sometimes Removing Breast Tissue Can Create a Better Augmentation Result
It may seem counterintuitive to remove breast tissue while simultaneously adding an implant, but in selected patients this can create a more attractive breast shape.
Some women have a disproportionate amount of their natural breast tissue concentrated in the lower portion of the breast, with relatively little fullness in the upper breast. Simply lifting all of this tissue may improve breast position but may not create the upper-pole fullness or overall shape the patient desires.
In these situations, some of the lower-pole breast tissue can be removed as part of the lift, while an implant is used to replace that volume in a more favorable position.
Rather than simply making the breast larger, the implant helps change where the volume is distributed. This can provide greater upper-pole fullness and projection while allowing the lower portion of the breast to be reduced, tightened, and reshaped.
This illustrates an important principle in breast surgery: sometimes the best result does not come from preserving every bit of existing breast volume. It comes from removing volume where it is poorly positioned and replacing it where it contributes more effectively to the desired breast shape and proportions.
Think About Shape and Size Separately
When planning breast surgery, I find it useful to initially think about the lift and augmentation as separate decisions, even when they will ultimately be performed together.
First:
What breast shape are we trying to create?
Where should the breast sit? Where should the nipple and areola sit? How much loose skin needs to be removed? How should the breast relate to the chest and torso?
Then:
What volume and proportion does the patient want?
Does she want to remain approximately the same size? Does she want more upper-breast fullness? Does she want a modest increase in volume or a substantially larger breast?
Once those questions are answered, we can determine whether the desired result is best achieved with a lift, augmentation, fat transfer, or a combination of techniques.
Do I Need a Breast Lift, Augmentation, or Both?
A useful starting point is to look in the mirror and ask yourself what actually bothers you.
If you like your breast shape and position but wish your breasts were larger or fuller, augmentation may be enough.
If you like your breast volume but dislike sagging, excess skin, or the position of your nipples, a breast lift may be the more important procedure.
If you want both a different shape and additional volume, a breast lift with augmentation may provide greater control over the final result.
If you want only a modest increase in volume or improvement in a specific area, fat transfer or redistribution of your own tissues may sometimes accomplish the goal without an implant.
Most importantly, you do not need to know which operation you need before your consultation. You need to know what you would like to change.
The Goal Is Not Simply Bigger or Higher Breasts
Ultimately, breast surgery is about proportion.
The ideal breast is not defined simply by cup size, implant size, or nipple height. The breast should have a shape, volume, and position that complement the patient’s chest, torso, shoulders, waist, and overall physique.
A breast lift and breast augmentation are powerful procedures individually, but they accomplish different things. When those differences are understood and the procedures are combined appropriately, they provide tremendous flexibility to reshape, resize, and rebalance the breasts while creating a result that fits the individual patient.
For women considering breast augmentation or breast lift surgery in Walnut Creek and the San Francisco Bay Area, one of the most common questions is whether changing breast size, breast shape, or both will best achieve their goals.
The question therefore should not simply be:
“Do I need a lift or implants?”
A better question is:
“What changes in shape and volume will give me the breast shape and proportions I want?”
That is the starting point for developing the right surgical plan.
Learn More
Breast Augmentation Before & After Gallery